Modern Marriage
Olivia Petter’s Times essay about why men are withdrawing from dating reads like another gloomy dispatch from the miserable front lines of heterosexual romance. Women in their thirties feel time pressing upon them, particularly if they want children; men of the same age often feel they have more time and recoil from encounters freighted with expectations. Beem there done that as a single mother so I know those observations to be true even a decade and half ago. Life has only grown more complicated since. Apps make people disposable, social media turns private disappointments into indictments of an entire sex, and even paying for dinner becomes another source of resentment. Men ghost, women get “the ick,” and the parties arrive at the next encounter carrying grievances from the last. Petter wonders whether heterosexual dating has reached rock bottom.It is also worth considering why we have designed such an extraordinarily difficult mechanism for accomplishing something societies once considered fairly mundane: finding someone to marry.
Arranged marriage, for all its imperfections, solves several of these problems rather accidentally. It removes the elaborate dance around why two people are meeting. Nobody needs to pretend to be casually interested while privately calculating suitabilty for having children, finances and long-term compatibility. The premise is established well before the first meeting: both people are open to marriage and are deciding whether they might plausibly marry each other. It separates the pressure to find a spouse from the pressure to make this particular encounter work. One introduction is one among a series for both parties, with families or matchmakers carrying some of the burden of finding the next candidate in the prospect pipeline. Rejection can therefore mean simply that the match was wrong rather than that the entire search has failed though given enough time and iterations it could feel that way.
The arrangement also introduces useful scarcity. A promising candidate may be meeting someone else next week, and that meeting may work. Dating apps encourage the opposite psychology: an effectively infinite supply of alternatives creates the suspicion that someone marginally better is always another swipe away. Arranged marriage can make alternatives finite and reciprocal. You have options, but so does the person sitting opposite you and their pipeline maybe more robust than yours. You don't have insight into how their prospects are being sourced as you are not both on the same dating platform. With the assymetry in place, the relevant question goes from “Could somebody better exist?”—to which the answer is almost always yes—to “Is this person sufficiently good that I would regret losing them while continuing to search?” This creates an incentive to decide without requiring either party to manufacture artificial urgency.
The weakness, of course, is that arranged marriage can be remarkably good at evaluating what is easy to measure and remarkably poor at discovering what matters inside a marriage. Education, occupation, family, religion and income are visible before the wedding; generosity, adaptability, sexual compatibility, conflict behavior and the ability to remain interesting on an uneventful Wednesday evening are not. Dating, at its best, reveals precisely these things. But Petter’s world has the opposite problem: it produces enormous amounts of interpersonal experience without necessarily establishing that the participants are pursuing the same destination. People can spend months together before discovering that one regards the relationship as progressing toward marriage while the other regards it as pleasant companionship. Arranged marriage provides structure without enough actionable insights into who the person really is; contemporary dating can potentially provide such inights but without enough structure, even getting to that point gets very complicated as the essay notes.
The next frontier of matchmaking may therefore lie between them. Keep what arranged marriage does well: establish intentions beforehand, screen for fundamental incompatibilities, create a pipeline of plausible candidates and remove the performance of pretending not to want what one actually wants. Then borrow the great informational advantage of dating: time. Instead of moving quickly from introduction to engagement, give two people enough shared experience to encounter disagreement, boredom, money, friends, family obligations, competing ambitions and ordinary yet aggravating inconvenience. Matchmaking would then become less about predicting compatibility from profiles and more about creating circumstances in which compatibility can reveal itself. Arrange the introduction, establish the destination, remove the games and then let two people date long enough to discover whether they should actually marry.
Arranged marriage, for all its imperfections, solves several of these problems rather accidentally. It removes the elaborate dance around why two people are meeting. Nobody needs to pretend to be casually interested while privately calculating suitabilty for having children, finances and long-term compatibility. The premise is established well before the first meeting: both people are open to marriage and are deciding whether they might plausibly marry each other. It separates the pressure to find a spouse from the pressure to make this particular encounter work. One introduction is one among a series for both parties, with families or matchmakers carrying some of the burden of finding the next candidate in the prospect pipeline. Rejection can therefore mean simply that the match was wrong rather than that the entire search has failed though given enough time and iterations it could feel that way.
The arrangement also introduces useful scarcity. A promising candidate may be meeting someone else next week, and that meeting may work. Dating apps encourage the opposite psychology: an effectively infinite supply of alternatives creates the suspicion that someone marginally better is always another swipe away. Arranged marriage can make alternatives finite and reciprocal. You have options, but so does the person sitting opposite you and their pipeline maybe more robust than yours. You don't have insight into how their prospects are being sourced as you are not both on the same dating platform. With the assymetry in place, the relevant question goes from “Could somebody better exist?”—to which the answer is almost always yes—to “Is this person sufficiently good that I would regret losing them while continuing to search?” This creates an incentive to decide without requiring either party to manufacture artificial urgency.
The weakness, of course, is that arranged marriage can be remarkably good at evaluating what is easy to measure and remarkably poor at discovering what matters inside a marriage. Education, occupation, family, religion and income are visible before the wedding; generosity, adaptability, sexual compatibility, conflict behavior and the ability to remain interesting on an uneventful Wednesday evening are not. Dating, at its best, reveals precisely these things. But Petter’s world has the opposite problem: it produces enormous amounts of interpersonal experience without necessarily establishing that the participants are pursuing the same destination. People can spend months together before discovering that one regards the relationship as progressing toward marriage while the other regards it as pleasant companionship. Arranged marriage provides structure without enough actionable insights into who the person really is; contemporary dating can potentially provide such inights but without enough structure, even getting to that point gets very complicated as the essay notes.
The next frontier of matchmaking may therefore lie between them. Keep what arranged marriage does well: establish intentions beforehand, screen for fundamental incompatibilities, create a pipeline of plausible candidates and remove the performance of pretending not to want what one actually wants. Then borrow the great informational advantage of dating: time. Instead of moving quickly from introduction to engagement, give two people enough shared experience to encounter disagreement, boredom, money, friends, family obligations, competing ambitions and ordinary yet aggravating inconvenience. Matchmaking would then become less about predicting compatibility from profiles and more about creating circumstances in which compatibility can reveal itself. Arrange the introduction, establish the destination, remove the games and then let two people date long enough to discover whether they should actually marry.
Filed under:
Marriage